"Chandelier" vs. "It's Like Summer"

Chloe was selected to portray young Lux in the video, "It's Like Summer." She was beautiful and did a great job playing the lead singer.

Here's the clip. http://youtu.be/qhgbT4g3M8M

ALSO https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A3oK_Iz6XjM

Many people have said that Chloe was the first to be selected for a music video, in response to Maddie appearing in "Chandelier," "Cry" and "Elastic Heart."

Maddie, Chandelier. http://youtu.be/2vjPBrBU-TM

It has been largely accepted that the Lux video was set-up for the purposes of Dance Moms.

Do you think that "It's Like Summer" was REALLY equal to the videos that Maddie performed in? Do you think that the Lux video would have been created without producer involvement?